Why Italy’s 2010 Oscar Entry Was a Surprising Choice
Key points
Italy’s submission for the 2010 Academy Awards was the family dramedy La Prima Cosa Bella (The First Beautiful Thing), directed by Paolo Virzì. Despite winning three David di Donatello Awards and multiple Nastri d’Argento awards, the film has left many viewers, especially those outside of Italy, puzzled about its selection for such a prestigious honor. Here’s a closer look at what makes this film a topic of debate.
A Tale of Family, Misconceptions, and Reconciliation
La Prima Cosa Bella revolves around Bruno Michelucci, a man in his forties who reluctantly returns to his hometown when he learns that his mother, Anna, is terminally ill. Played masterfully by Stefania Sandrelli, Anna is a character whose past is marked by misconceptions and gossip, which ultimately led to Bruno’s estrangement from her and his sister Valeria.
Through a series of flashbacks, the film reveals Anna’s story—how she left her jealous husband to raise her children on her own, facing immense struggles but also finding moments of happiness. The heart of the film lies in Bruno’s journey towards reconciling with his mother and sister, and understanding the strength and goodness that Anna embodied despite being judged harshly by society.
A Slow Burn with a Powerful Finale
The first three-quarters of La Prima Cosa Bella can be challenging for viewers, as the film takes its time to build up the narrative. The portrayal of the characters in their younger years feels less engaging, with the performances of the younger actors falling short compared to those of their adult counterparts. However, it’s in the last half hour that the film truly shines. The narrative becomes more compelling, and the performances of the adult actors bring a depth that was missing earlier.
This shift in tone and quality is where the film finally resonates with its audience. The story of a son coming to terms with his past and his mother’s sacrifices becomes poignant and emotionally impactful, making the final moments worth the wait.
A Controversial Oscar Submission
Despite its strengths, many, particularly non-Italian audiences, found La Prima Cosa Bella to be a heavy, exaggerated melodrama. The film’s selection as Italy’s submission for the 2010 Oscars was met with surprise, especially considering other strong contenders like Mine Vaganti (Loose Cannons) or Io Sono L’Amore (I Am Love), which had more universally appealing stories and internationally renowned actors.
The Academy’s choices are often unpredictable, and La Prima Cosa Bella is a testament to that. While it may not have been the most obvious choice, its portrayal of family dynamics, misconceptions, and the redemptive power of reconciliation offers a unique, albeit slow, cinematic experience.
Nostalgia Through Music
One of the film’s highlights is its soundtrack, particularly the old songs that evoke a sense of nostalgia. Nicola Di Bari’s “La Prima Cosa Bella” stands out, transporting viewers back to a time when these songs were popular and beloved. For many, this music was the most memorable and enjoyable aspect of the film, adding an emotional layer that complemented the story.
