January 29 - Freethinkers Day

nPosted on January 29, 2018

Key Points

nToday is Freethinkers Day.

n
n

nWay back when, I mentioned that October 12 is Free Thought Day.

nFreethought (or free thought) isn’t just thinking any old thing, whatever you want, whimsically flitting from playful thought to fun conspiracy theory to mysterious belief to comforting assurance.

nInstead, a freethinker is someone who bases her or his ideas on rational thought, on evidence, on science, on reason – as opposed to basing ideas on tradition, authority, or revelation.

nThe reason that we celebrate freethinkers today is because it is the birthday of Thomas Paine, whose impactful pamphlet Common Sense is credited with inspiring the American Revolution, when the 13 American colonies declared independence from Britain. Paine wrote other essays about ending slavery and promoting human rights. He was ahead of his time…and he pushed the world into becoming a better place!

nCheck out the earlier post about Paine (link above) for more on this great freethinker. Or delve into freethought by reading or listening to these identically named items:

nCheck out the earlier post about Paine (link above) for more on this great freethinker. Or delve into freethought by reading or listening to these completely different yet identically named items:

nHow do we know what is true?

nHow do we know what is true? video

nHere are some questions for you. Three of these things really happened to my daughters when they were kids, and one of them happened to me when I was a college student.

Would you believe your teacher’s claim that Egyptian pharaohs lived in the pyramids?

Would you let your friend’s mom pour melted wax into your ear to purify your body from toxins?

Would you believe your good friend’s statement that dinosaur fossils were buried by the Devil to trick people?

Would you believe people who experienced a revelation from God that a pregnant woman in the Bible study group was NOT going to give birth to a human baby, but instead to something new and special and different?

n
n

nHere’s how these events panned out for my family:

My daughter had heard several times that the Egyptian pyramids were burial places for ancient kings – not houses where they lived. When her teacher taught the latter to the class, she questioned the teacher. The teacher got embarrassed but seemed to double down on her statement. My daughter was puzzled. She let it drop in class, but she wondered if her previous knowledge (pyramid = burial place and monument, not house for living, breathing pharaoh) was wrong.

But she remembered the diagrams of the secret doors, the burial chambers, and so forth. She thought about the fact that the pyramids had no windows or ordinary doors. She was sure that her teacher was wrong – even though she was the teacher! After class she told me about her concerns. I discussed the matter with the teacher, but I made sure to allow the teacher to save face and claim that my daughter had misunderstood her (even though another student confirmed my daughter’s version).
n
n

n
The point here is, don’t assume that an authority figure is always right. Question statements that fly in the face of everything you thought you knew – but do consider the possibility that the new statement MIGHT be correct, and the old “knowledge” wrong. Use further research, observation, experiment, or reason to figure out which is more likely.

My daughter had been taught not to put things in her ears, in general. If a bug crawls or flies into an ear, she knew from MY bad experience, we could pour cooking oil into the ear to gently flush it out. But by and large, we don’t stick objects or substances into our ears.

nAlso, my daughter was really skeptical about wax in an ear canal being able to do anything about poisons inside the body. Yes, our bodies make wax in our ears to keep the canals moist and infection-free, and to make sure dust and other bad stuff doesn’t get too deep in the ear – but the ear canal ends in the eardrum. If there were something bad (like snake toxin?) in someone’s bloodstream, neither his own natural earwax nor wax from a candle would do a thing to save his life! If someone ate food that had gone bad, or the wrong kind of mushrooms, or weed killer – again, any sort of wax in the ear canal can’t do a thing to help!

The point here is that there is a lot of B.S. about health, nutrition, and medicine.

My daughter suspected that this candling practice was an example of “alternative medicine” that didn’t stand up to its claims. So she said no, thank you, and later she told me about the incident. I was able to show her a magazine article with results of experiments about candling – and it showed my daughter that her B.S. detector was in working order!

My daughter knew that different families and individuals have different religious traditions and beliefs – and that most (or all?) religious beliefs are based on faith, not evidence. My daughter knew that there was LOTS of evidence about evolution and about dinosaurs, including many different sorts of fossils (not just fossilized bones) – but she also knew that many religious groups were upset and negative about the concept of evolution.

In this particular case, my daughter didn’t argue or even discuss her friend’s claim. She shrugged it off and continued
n

nto enjoy the museum exhibits of dinosaur fossils. The point here is, even if a really good friend believes something that goes against evidence, you don’t have to follow him or her into that belief.

nI was bewildered about all these smart, cool young adults believing that the pregnant woman wasn’t growing a human baby.

nBack in those days, there was no ultrasound technology to image the baby in the womb, but there were kicks and a heartbeat, and the doctors assured the woman that her pregnancy was normal.

nIt was clear to me that she was having a baby.

nBut thirty or more people clung to the idea that it was going to be something else, something more miraculous yet strange. Something not human. And they thought that because one member claimed that he’d had a revelation from God.

nI shook my head over the situation for months. Finally, the baby was born.

nA healthy HUMAN baby.

nAt that point the young man who had had the original revelation finally had another revelation telling him that the first revelation was wrong – and yes, this was a perfectly ordinary baby after all…

nThe point here is that revelation isn’t a reliable path to the truth.