The Silent Movie Theatre: A Hollywood Legend with a Ghostly Past
Nestled on Fairfax Avenue in Los Angeles, the Silent Movie Theatre stands as a testament to Hollywood’s golden age—and its darker, more mysterious side. Since 1942, this iconic venue has been a cultural landmark, a hub for film enthusiasts, and, surprisingly, a hotspot for paranormal activity. But how did this charming little theatre become one of LA’s most haunted places? Let’s dive into its fascinating—and sometimes tragic—history.
The Birth of a Cinematic Gem
In 1942, John Hampton, a passionate film collector, opened the Silent Movie Theatre. This was just 15 years after silent films had faded from the mainstream, replaced by “talkies.” Hampton, however, wasn’t ready to let the magic of silent cinema die. He started with his personal collection of classics, showcasing legends like Charlie Chaplin, Mary Pickford, and Buster Keaton. Over time, he expanded his library, preserving these films for future generations.
But Hampton’s dedication came at a cost. To maintain his collection, he stored film reels in chemicals kept in a tub above the theatre. Over the years, exposure to these toxic substances took a toll on his health. Diagnosed with cancer in the 1970s, Hampton passed away in 1990, leaving behind a legacy—and, some say, his ghost.
Tragedy Strikes: The Laurence Austin Era
After Hampton’s death, the theatre changed hands, and Laurence Austin took over. But his tenure was cut short in January 1997 under shocking circumstances. Initially, it was believed Austin was killed during a robbery. However, the truth was far more sinister.
Police discovered that Austin’s business partner and longtime lover, James Van Sickle, had hired a hitman to murder him. Van Sickle’s motive? Money. Both he and the gunman were sentenced to life in prison, but the theatre’s fate seemed sealed. It closed its doors that same year, leaving fans and employees heartbroken.
A New Chapter: Charlie Lustman’s Revival
In 1999, the theatre found a new lease on life when Charlie Lustman purchased it. Walking into the space, Lustman was struck by its history—faded bloodstains on the carpet, vintage posters on the walls, and an undeniable sense of nostalgia. He later claimed that John Hampton’s spirit inspired him to restore the theatre to its former glory.
Lustman renovated the 158-seat venue, adding fresh paint, new wooden floors, and a neon marquee. He kept the tradition of live piano or organ accompaniment for screenings, staying true to Hampton’s vision. But it wasn’t long before strange occurrences began to unsettle Lustman and his staff.
Ghosts of the Silent Movie Theatre
The theatre’s haunted reputation quickly became apparent. Employees reported eerie phenomena, from unexplained noises to shadowy figures. John Hampton’s spirit is said to linger in the lounge area of the upstairs apartment, where he and his wife, Dorothy, lived for 45 years.
Lustman himself experienced the supernatural firsthand. When he decided to host a 3-D film festival in 2000, things went awry. A display case mysteriously gave him a black eye, and the projector—which had worked flawlessly for a year—broke down minutes before the first screening. It seemed Hampton’s ghost was unhappy with the deviation from silent films.
Then there’s Laurence Austin’s spirit, which has been spotted in the lobby near where he was murdered. Lustman and a former publicist reported hearing the distinct jingle of keys—a nervous habit Austin was known for. To calm the activity, Lustman brought in a shaman, burned sage, and placed rose crystals at the murder site.
The Theatre Today: A Blend of Past and Present
In 2006, Lustman sold the theatre to the Harkham brothers, who reopened it as The Cinefamily. While they expanded the programming to include sound films, they continued to honor the venue’s silent film roots. Today, the theatre hosts an eclectic mix of screenings and special events, attracting film buffs and history enthusiasts alike.
Located on the west side of Fairfax Avenue, just north of the Farmers Market, the Silent Movie Theatre remains a beloved LA landmark. It’s also a popular spot for ghost hunters and paranormal investigators. Imagine hosting a classic horror flick night or a ghost hunt in this historic venue—it doesn’t get much spookier than that!
Why the Silent Movie Theatre Still Matters
The Silent Movie Theatre isn’t just a relic of the past; it’s a living, breathing piece of Hollywood history. Its walls hold stories of passion, tragedy, and resilience. From John Hampton’s tireless dedication to Laurence Austin’s untimely demise, the theatre’s history is as captivating as the films it showcases.
And let’s not forget the ghosts. Whether you’re a skeptic or a believer, there’s no denying the eerie allure of this haunted venue. It’s a place where the past and present collide, where the silver screen meets the supernatural.
Final Thoughts
So, what makes the Silent Movie Theatre so special? Is it the timeless films, the rich history, or the ghostly legends? Perhaps it’s all of the above. One thing’s for sure: this Fairfax Avenue gem is more than just a theatre—it’s a cultural icon with a story to tell.
Next time you’re in Los Angeles, why not stop by? Who knows? You might just catch a glimpse of John Hampton or Laurence Austin, still keeping watch over their beloved theatre.